Classification of Chemical Indicators: Types, Principles, and Applications in Sterilization

By -

Chemical indicators play a crucial role in the monitoring and validation of sterilization processes in pharmaceutical, microbiological, and healthcare industries. They provide a visual confirmation that a sterilization cycle has achieved the desired conditions, such as temperature, time, and steam penetration. Understanding the classification of chemical indicators helps ensure effective sterilization and regulatory compliance as per international standards like ISO 11140 and WHO GMP.

🧪 What are Chemical Indicators?

A chemical indicator (CI) is a device or material designed to respond to one or more parameters of a sterilization process by changing its chemical or physical characteristics. These changes (usually color changes) provide visual evidence that the sterilization conditions were met.

Chemical indicators are not a replacement for biological indicators but serve as immediate and practical tools for day-to-day monitoring of sterilization efficiency.

🎯 Purpose of Chemical Indicators

  • To verify exposure to specific sterilization parameters (temperature, time, steam, or gas).
  • To detect sterilization failures due to improper loading or process deviations.
  • To distinguish between processed and unprocessed materials.
  • To ensure that every sterilized pack, load, or cycle meets quality requirements.
  • To support documentation for quality assurance and validation activities.

⚗️ Principle of Chemical Indicators

The principle of a chemical indicator is based on a chemical reaction or physical change that occurs when the indicator is exposed to specific sterilization conditions. This reaction usually results in a color change or visible transformation that confirms exposure.

For example, a chemical indicator may contain dyes or chemical compounds that change color when exposed to a certain temperature, humidity, or sterilant gas (like ethylene oxide or hydrogen peroxide).

📘 Classification of Chemical Indicators (as per ISO 11140-1:2014)

According to ISO 11140-1 standards, chemical indicators are classified into six main classes based on their intended use and performance characteristics.

🔹 Class 1 – Process Indicators

Also known as process indicators or exposure indicators. They are designed to indicate that an item has been exposed to the sterilization process.

  • Used on the outside of packs (e.g., autoclave tape).
  • Change color after exposure to sterilization conditions.
  • Example: Autoclave tape changing from beige to black after steam exposure.

🔹 Class 2 – Indicators for Specific Tests

These indicators are used for specific performance tests such as the Bowie-Dick test for steam sterilizers.

  • Designed to evaluate air removal and steam penetration in vacuum-assisted sterilizers.
  • Example: Bowie-Dick test pack changes uniform color after a successful vacuum cycle.

🔹 Class 3 – Single Parameter Indicators

These indicators respond to only one critical parameter of the sterilization process, such as temperature or time.

  • Used for specific parameter verification.
  • Example: Chemical spot that changes color when 121°C temperature is achieved.

🔹 Class 4 – Multi-Parameter Indicators

These indicators react to two or more critical parameters (e.g., temperature and time, or temperature and steam).

  • Provide better assurance than single parameter indicators.
  • Used inside packs or pouches to confirm internal exposure.
  • Example: Internal indicator strip placed inside surgical trays or instrument packs.

🔹 Class 5 – Integrating Indicators

Class 5 chemical indicators are integrating indicators that react to all critical parameters of the sterilization process and provide performance similar to a biological indicator.

  • Provide high-level confirmation of sterilization effectiveness.
  • Can be used as a reliable alternative to biological indicators for routine monitoring.
  • Example: Integrator strips used in steam sterilizers that simulate microbial kill conditions.

🔹 Class 6 – Emulating Indicators

Also known as cycle verification indicators. These indicators are designed to react to all critical parameters of a specific sterilization cycle.

  • Provide very precise end-point indication.
  • Highly sensitive and used for specific cycle programs (e.g., 134°C for 3 minutes).
  • Example: Class 6 indicator used in hospital sterilizers to validate a defined cycle.

📊 Comparison of Chemical Indicator Classes

Class Indicator Type Purpose Example
Class 1 Process Indicator Shows exposure to sterilization Autoclave tape
Class 2 Test Indicator Used for specific tests (e.g., Bowie-Dick) Bowie-Dick test sheet
Class 3 Single Parameter Responds to one critical parameter Temperature-sensitive dots
Class 4 Multi-Parameter Responds to multiple critical parameters Internal pack indicators
Class 5 Integrating Indicator Simulates microbial kill conditions Steam integrator strip
Class 6 Emulating Indicator Cycle-specific end-point indicator Cycle verification indicator

🧫 Applications of Chemical Indicators

  • Used in autoclaves, dry heat ovens, and ethylene oxide sterilizers.
  • Applied on or inside packaging materials for load identification.
  • Used in Bowie-Dick tests to check vacuum efficiency.
  • Integrated with sterilization pouches and wraps for color verification.
  • Essential for validation and requalification of sterilization cycles.

📏 Acceptance Criteria for Chemical Indicators

The acceptance of chemical indicators depends on visual inspection:

  • Uniform and complete color change after sterilization.
  • No partial or patchy color transition.
  • Results must be interpreted immediately after the cycle is complete.
  • Indicators must conform to ISO 11140-1 performance requirements.

🧠 Key Differences Between Chemical and Biological Indicators

Parameter Chemical Indicator Biological Indicator
Response Type Chemical or color change Spore growth or inactivation
Result Time Immediate (visual) Requires incubation (24–48 hrs)
Purpose Routine monitoring Performance validation
Regulatory Standard ISO 11140 ISO 11138

📚 Conclusion

The classification of chemical indicators provides a systematic approach to monitoring and validating sterilization processes. From basic process indicators to advanced integrating and emulating indicators, each class serves a specific function in ensuring sterilization effectiveness and safety.

For pharmaceutical, microbiological, and healthcare sterilization systems, using the correct class of indicator ensures compliance with international standards and enhances patient safety by confirming sterilization success in every load.

💬 About the Author

Siva Sankar is a Pharmaceutical Microbiology Consultant and Auditor with extensive experience in sterility testing, validation, and GMP compliance. He provides consultancy, training, and documentation services for pharmaceutical microbiology and cleanroom practices.

📧 Contact: siva17092@gmail.com
📱 Mobile: 09505626106

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and does not replace your laboratory’s SOPs or regulatory guidance. Always follow validated methods and manufacturer instructions.

Popular posts from this blog

Non-Viable particle count (NVPC)

By -
Image
Particle mater in room air limits are in particles of 0.5 μm and larger per cubic meter. ISO = cubic meter (m 3 ) FD Standard 209 E = cubic feet (ft 3 )   ISO class equal to federal standard 209 E class .  1m 3  = 35.31 ft 3 1m = 100 cm Adapted from former Federal Standard No. 209 E,                ISO = international organization for standard 14644 part -1, may -1999 p ublished. Maximum concentration limits (particles M3 of air) for particles equal to and larger than the considered sizes shown below: (a) ISO Classification Number(N) 0.1µm 0.2µm 0.3µm 0.5µm 1.0µm 5.0µm ISO 1 b                    10 d                 2 d d d e ISO 2 10...
Read more

TNTC vs TFTC

By -
Image
Too Numerous To Count (TNTC) or Too Many To Counts (TMTC) In samples with very high bacterial concentration, that is not suitable for counting (unable to get accurate counts) and reports the results as "to numerous to count" (TNTC). While the best solution is to collect another sample and dilute to get a more accurate counts, this might not always to be possible. Ideally one plate with 200 to 250 colonies are used. Counts above 250 are considered "to numerous to count" (TNTC), because it is impossible to count the colonies. plates countable range 25 to 250. Too Few To Count (TFTC): If there are less than 30 colonies on the plate, small errors in dilution technique or the presence of a few contaminants will have a drastic effect on the final count this count is called too few to count (TFTC).
Read more

Alert and Action Limits

By -
In pharmaceuticals alert and action limits are very important, because these limits are effective control to the process. alert and action limits are in house limits, these limits must be less than guideline limits or define limits. Alert and action limits defined based on trend analysis. alert and action limits are like a barrier before the guideline limits. Alert Limit: To be alert the microbial counts reach to this alert level. It is nor necessary to take any action. Possible deviation from normal process condition This is a trigger, that something is going wrong means microbial count increasing that area. Action Limits: When microbial count reach this action limits then action is mandatory. To control the  microbial count in the area. Signal an apparent deviation from normal process condition And require immediate action. If not controlled, we might get area failure. These alert and action limits must be less than final limits. Example : A...
Read more