Fumigation vs Fogging in Pharmaceutical Microbiology: Key Differences and Best Practices

-


Author: Siva Sankar, Pharmaceutical Microbiology Consultant
Category: Cleanroom Sanitization / Microbiology Practices
Updated: October 2025

🔍 Introduction

Maintaining microbial control in pharmaceutical cleanrooms and microbiology labs is critical to ensure product sterility and regulatory compliance. Two common disinfection methods used are fumigation and fogging. Although these terms are often used interchangeably, they differ in chemical, process, and regulatory acceptance.

🧫 What is Fumigation?

Fumigation involves vaporizing a disinfectant chemical, typically formaldehyde gas, to sterilize a closed environment. The gas penetrates surfaces and equipment, killing microorganisms including bacterial spores.

  • Chemical Used: Formaldehyde + Potassium permanganate (KMnO₄)
  • Advantages: High-level disinfection, effective against spores
  • Disadvantages: Carcinogenic, corrosive, leaves residues, banned by WHO and GMP for pharmaceutical use
  • Regulatory Status: Discontinued as per WHO TRS 961 (Annex 6)

🌫️ What is Fogging?

Fogging uses a fine mist (aerosol) of a liquid disinfectant—commonly Hydrogen Peroxide (H₂O₂) or Peracetic Acid (PAA)—dispersed into the air using a fogger machine. It ensures uniform distribution and rapid surface contact without leaving harmful residues.

  • Chemical Used: 6–12% Hydrogen Peroxide, or Peracetic Acid solutions
  • Advantages: Non-toxic residue, safe for equipment, GMP-accepted
  • Disadvantages: Requires good air circulation and validated contact time
  • Regulatory Status: Recommended by EU GMP Annex 1 and ISO 14644

⚗️ Comparative Summary

Parameter Fumigation Fogging
Chemical Used Formaldehyde + KMnO₄ Hydrogen Peroxide or Peracetic Acid
Residue Toxic, carcinogenic Water and oxygen only
Time Required Overnight (8–12 hrs) 2–4 hrs
GMP Approval Not accepted Approved
Effectiveness High High and safer
Safety Requires PPE and neutralization Safe with ventilation

🏭 Best Practice Recommendation

Modern pharmaceutical facilities should replace formaldehyde fumigation with Hydrogen Peroxide (H₂O₂) fogging or Vaporized Hydrogen Peroxide (VHP) systems. These methods comply with GMP, are environment-friendly, and reduce operator exposure risks.

📋 Fogging Procedure Overview

  1. Seal the cleanroom and switch off AHU.
  2. Prepare the required quantity of disinfectant (e.g., 6% H₂O₂).
  3. Use an ULV fogger; position it at a central location.
  4. Start fogging and ensure fine mist distribution.
  5. Allow minimum 2–4 hrs contact time.
  6. Switch on AHU and ventilate area before entry.

📚 References

  • WHO TRS 961, Annex 6 — GMP for Sterile Pharmaceutical Products
  • EU GMP Annex 1 (2023) — Manufacture of Sterile Medicinal Products
  • ISO 14644 — Cleanroom Standards

👨‍🔬 About the Author

Siva Sankar is a Pharmaceutical Microbiology Consultant with extensive experience in GMP audits, cleanroom validation, and aseptic process assurance. He provides training, audit consultancy, and technical guidance for pharma industries seeking compliance excellence.

Contact: siva17092@gmail.com | +91 9505626106

Follow this blog for more pharma microbiology insights and practical guidance.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and does not replace your laboratory’s SOPs or regulatory guidance. Always follow validated methods and manufacturer instructions.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is the difference between Equipment and Instrument

-
Image
Equipment is the machine that's processing the work and the instrument is to measure the data that comes out of the machine to get feed back of the machine and the process. Equipment used for a specific work and instrument is measuring parameters. Like temperature and pressure. Instruments are part of equipment, number of instruments comprises a equipment. Equipment is processing (attach with large assembly) device but instrument is measuring device (small assembly). Example : Autoclave is a equipment and in autoclave pressure gauge and temperature sensor is an instrument.
Read more

Alert and Action Limits

-
In pharmaceuticals alert and action limits are very important, because these limits are effective control to the process. alert and action limits are in house limits, these limits must be less than guideline limits or define limits. Alert and action limits defined based on trend analysis. alert and action limits are like a barrier before the guideline limits. Alert Limit: To be alert the microbial counts reach to this alert level. It is nor necessary to take any action. Possible deviation from normal process condition This is a trigger, that something is going wrong means microbial count increasing that area. Action Limits: When microbial count reach this action limits then action is mandatory. To control the  microbial count in the area. Signal an apparent deviation from normal process condition And require immediate action. If not controlled, we might get area failure. These alert and action limits must be less than final limits. Example : A...
Read more

How to calculate the log reduction?

-
Image
·          "Log reduction" is a mathematical term (as is "log increase") used to show the relative number of live microbes eliminated from a surface by disinfecting or cleaning. ·          For example, a "5-log reduction" means lowering the number of microorganisms by 100,000-fold, that is, if a surface has 100,000 pathogenic microbes on it, a 5-log reduction would reduce the number of microorganisms to one. Log Reductions 1 log reduction means the number of germs is 10 times smaller (10 1 ) 2 log reduction means the number of germs is 100 times smaller (10 2 ) 3 log reduction means the number of germs is 1000 times smaller(10 3 ) 4 log reduction means the number of germs is 10,000 times smaller(10 4 ) 5 log reduction means the number of germs is 100,000 times smaller(10 5 ) 6 log reduction means the number of germs is 1,000,000 times smaller(10 6 ) 7 log reduction means the number of ger...
Read more